Why the Libertarian Party Needs to Recognize the Necessity of Government, Law, and National Borders

I have been involved with the Libertarian Party since around 1982. In those forty-plus years, I have watched the Party evolve, sometimes for the better and sometimes for the worse.

One thing that has increasingly concerned me is the apparent inability of some Libertarians to distinguish between limited government and no government at all. 

I became involved with the Libertarian Party because I believed in individual liberty, personal responsibility, private property rights, and a government whose powers were strictly limited. 

I did not become a Libertarian because I believed society could function without government.  And after more than four decades, I still don't.

The question isn't whether government should exist. It will exist. The question is what its legitimate functions should be and how we prevent it from exceeding them.

A State Will Exist

Whether we like it or not, government is going to exist.  There has never been a modern, industrialized nation that has successfully operated for an extended period without some form of government exercising authority over a defined territory.That does not mean every government is legitimate, nor does it justify every power governments claim. It simply recognizes reality. 

People will disagree. Contracts will be broken. Property will be stolen. Individuals will commit acts of violence against other individuals.  And someone will have to resolve those disputes.

We can call that institution a government, a private arbitration system, or something else entirely. But once an organization possesses the recognized authority to establish and enforce rules over a territory, we have recreated at least some of the functions of government.

The question is not whether coercive power will exist. The question is how that power will be constrained and held accountable.  The Founders understood this. They did not establish the United States Constitution to eliminate government. They established it to create a government with enumerated powers and limitations designed to protect individual liberty. They were not anarchists.

Neither am I.

Police and Courts Are Not the Enemy

One of the most important responsibilities of government is protecting individuals against aggression.

That requires law enforcement and an impartial judicial system. Suppose someone breaks into your home, steals your property, and assaults you. Who investigates? Who apprehends the offender? Who determines guilt? Who orders restitution? Who ensures that punishment is proportionate to the offense?

Certainly, individuals possess the right to defend themselves. But self-defense is not a substitute for a functioning system of justice. Nor should justice depend entirely on who can afford the most powerful private security company.

I support police who protect individual rights, not police who enforce victimless-crime laws, conduct unconstitutional searches, confiscate property without due process, or enjoy immunity for misconduct.

I support courts that adjudicate legitimate disputes, protect the accused, enforce contracts, and provide remedies for victims.

Those are not betrayals of libertarian principles.  They are among the reasons a limited government can be justified in the first place. 

The national Libertarian Party platform actually recognizes much of this in its provisions on crime, justice, and the protection of property rights. Yet Section 3.0 states that the only proper purpose of government, "should it exist," is the protection of individual rights.

Should it exist? 

I consider that qualification unnecessary and misleading.  A political party seeking to govern a constitutional republic ought to be capable of acknowledging that some government functions are necessary without endorsing an unlimited state.

The Problem With Open Borders 

This brings me to another issue on which I disagree with the national Party and the NJLP.

Open borders.

I understand the libertarian argument for freedom of movement. Individuals should generally be free to travel, work, trade, and associate with whomever they choose.

I also understand that immigrants have contributed enormously to this country.

But I reject the proposition that freedom of movement requires a nation to surrender meaningful control over who enters its territory.

A country that maintains a government, a legal system, public infrastructure, and national defense must also have a coherent immigration policy.

The national platform's Section 3.4 declares that economic freedom requires the unrestricted movement of human capital across national borders.

The NJLP platform's Section 15 goes further in opposing state immigration restrictions, while allowing limited control over foreign nationals who present credible threats. 

I believe both provisions need reconsideration. 

A national border is not identical to the boundary of a privately owned parcel. It defines the territory within which a government exercises legal jurisdiction and accepts responsibility for protecting rights.  The existence of that jurisdiction does not give government unlimited authority over peaceful individuals. But neither does it follow that a government must abandon its ability to determine who enters and under what conditions.

Consider the practical questions. How does a country identify individuals entering its territory? How does it distinguish peaceful migrants from fugitives or individuals presenting credible security threats? How does it enforce lawful removal orders while protecting due process? How does it reconcile immigration policy with public services financed through compulsory taxation?

Simply declaring that peaceful people should be free to cross borders does not resolve those questions. And although the overwhelming majority of immigrants may be peaceful, a government cannot reliably establish that every individual presents no threat without some reasonable process for determining identity and admissibility. 

That is not an argument for mass deportations, arbitrary detention, discrimination based on nationality, or treating immigrants as criminals merely because they were born elsewhere.  It is an argument for a functioning legal immigration system. 

I favor immigration that is lawful, orderly, reasonably accessible, and consistent with the protection of individual rights.  It should not be easy. American citizenship is a valuable asset and needs to be treated as such.

I oppose an immigration bureaucracy that makes lawful entry unnecessarily difficult. I also oppose treating national borders as though they have no legitimate purpose. 

Those positions are not mutually exclusive.

The Welfare State Complicates the Question 

There is another reality that advocates of unrestricted immigration must confront.

We do not live in a libertarian society. We live in a country with extensive taxpayer-funded programs, compulsory taxation, government schools, publicly financed healthcare, and a vast system of income transfers. In a genuinely free society, individuals would largely be responsible for supporting themselves through voluntary arrangements.

That is not the system we have. Consequently, immigration policy cannot be considered entirely in isolation from the welfare state.

The fiscal consequences of immigration vary considerably depending on employment, age, income, legal status, eligibility for benefits, and the level of government involved. It would be inaccurate to claim that every immigrant is a net financial burden.  Nevertheless, compulsory taxpayer financing creates legitimate questions about eligibility, responsibility, and the allocation of public resources. 

My preferred long-term solution is to dismantle the welfare state, not to expand immigration enforcement into every aspect of private life.  But until that happens, I do not believe the Party can simply pretend that the existing system is irrelevant. 

Libertarians should distinguish the society we ultimately want from the practical policies required to move toward it.

Property Rights Must Remain Central 

One of the strongest arguments against unrestricted government power is also one of the strongest arguments for a coherent system of law. 

Property rights. Individuals have the right to determine who enters their homes, businesses, and privately owned land. That right does not disappear because someone invokes freedom of movement.

At the same time, a property owner should generally be free to invite a peaceful foreign national onto private property, employ that person, or enter into a voluntary contract.

These rights can come into tension with immigration restrictions, and the Party ought to acknowledge that tension rather than pretending it does not exist.

I believe a defensible libertarian immigration policy must recognize both private property rights and the limited authority of a constitutional government to regulate entry into the country. Neither principle should automatically erase the other. 

What the Libertarian Party Should Change

The national Party and the NJLP should explicitly distinguish limited-government libertarianism from anarchism.

Anarcho-capitalists have every right to advocate their philosophy within the broader libertarian movement. But their philosophical objections to the existence of the state should not be mistaken for a consensus among Libertarians.

I would make several changes.

First, the platforms should recognize the legitimate functions of a strictly limited constitutional government, including protecting individual rights, maintaining courts, enforcing legitimate laws, and providing national defense. 

Second, they should distinguish legitimate law enforcement from government abuse. The existence of police is not inherently inconsistent with libertarianism. Unaccountable police power is.

Third, they should replace language endorsing unrestricted international migration with language recognizing freedom of movement alongside reasonable, constitutionally constrained border administration.

Fourth, they should defend due process for citizens and noncitizens alike, while recognizing the legitimate enforcement of immigration laws consistent with individual rights. 

Fifth, they should acknowledge that our long-term objectives and our transitional policies cannot always be identical. We cannot eliminate the welfare state, the regulatory state, and the existing immigration bureaucracy with the stroke of a pen. Political philosophy must be capable of functioning in the real world.

Liberty Requires More Than Opposition to Government

I became a Libertarian because I believe individuals should control their own lives.

I oppose government coercion when it violates individual rights. I oppose the redistribution of wealth, unnecessary regulation, unconstitutional searches, restrictions on peaceful conduct, and the seemingly endless expansion of government authority.

None of those convictions require me to pretend that police, courts, borders, or national defense are unnecessary.

Nor do they require me to accept anarchism as the logical conclusion of libertarian philosophy.

The proper objective is not a society in which nobody has the authority to protect individual rights.

It is a society in which the institutions entrusted with that authority are prohibited from abusing it.

The Libertarian Party should be advocating a government powerful enough to protect our rights, but sufficiently constrained that it cannot legitimately violate them.

That is the distinction I believe the national Party and the NJLP need to make.

We do not need unlimited government. We do not need no government. We need limited government.

And there is an enormous difference between the three.


Proposed Changes to the National LP and NJLP Platforms 

The following proposals reflect the limited-government position advocated in this article.

1. National LP — Section 3.0: Securing Liberty

Current concern: The platform describes the proper purpose of government with the qualification "should it exist." 

Proposed replacement:

We recognize the necessity of a limited constitutional government whose legitimate functions are confined to the protection of individual rights, the administration of justice, the enforcement of laws consistent with those rights, the adjudication of disputes, and defense against aggression.

Government authority must be strictly limited, subject to constitutional restraints, and accountable to the people. No government may legitimately exercise powers beyond those necessary to perform its proper functions. 

2. National LP — Section 1.7: Crime and Justice

Current concern: Although the platform recognizes due process and the administration of justice, it could more explicitly acknowledge the legitimate role of accountable law enforcement and independent courts.

Proposed addition:

We recognize that the protection of individual rights requires an impartial judicial system and law enforcement institutions accountable to the people. Police authority shall be limited to enforcing laws consistent with individual rights and constitutional protections. We oppose qualified immunity and other legal protections that improperly shield public officials from accountability for violations of those rights.

3. National LP — Section 3.4: Free Trade and Migration

Current concern: The platform endorses unrestricted international movement of human capital without adequately explaining the relationship between migration, national sovereignty, and border administration.

Proposed replacement:

We support freedom of movement, voluntary association, and peaceful international migration, subject to the legitimate authority of a constitutional government to administer national borders and protect individual rights.

Immigration procedures should be transparent, reasonable, nondiscriminatory, and consistent with due process. Government may establish lawful procedures for determining identity, admissibility, and credible threats to public safety or national security.

We oppose arbitrary detention, collective punishment, unreasonable restrictions on peaceful immigration, and immigration enforcement that violates constitutional rights.

4. NJLP — Statement of Principles

Current concern: The Party should make clear that the existence of limited government is compatible with libertarian principles.

Proposed addition:

The New Jersey Libertarian Party recognizes the necessity of limited constitutional government for the protection of individual rights, the impartial administration of justice, and the preservation of a free society.

We maintain that the legitimate authority of government derives from its obligation to protect life, liberty, and property, and that any exercise of governmental power beyond those legitimate purposes must be subject to strict scrutiny.

5. NJLP — Section 15: Immigration

Current concern: The Party should distinguish opposition to unjustified immigration restrictions from opposition to legitimate border administration.

Proposed replacement:

The New Jersey Libertarian Party recognizes freedom of movement, private property rights, voluntary employment, and freedom of association as fundamental libertarian principles.

We also recognize the legitimate authority of the federal government, within constitutional limits, to administer international borders and establish immigration procedures.

We oppose state policies that violate due process, discriminate arbitrarily, or interfere unnecessarily with peaceful private relationships. We support lawful cooperation between state and federal authorities when consistent with constitutional protections, individual rights, and the proper division of governmental powers.

We oppose taxpayer-funded benefits based solely on immigration status and support the gradual elimination of coercive redistribution programs for all persons.

One Member comment

  • Our immigration plank has long been a principle of the New Jersey and National Libertarian Parties. The earliest NJLP Platform I can find (June 1998) states:

    We hold that human rights should not be denied or abridged on the basis of nationality. We strongly oppose all measures that punish employers who hire undocumented workers. We oppose state immigration restrictions, whether for the purpose of cooperating with Federal restrictions or otherwise.

    Undocumented non-citizens should not be denied the fundamental freedom to labor and to move about unimpeded. We oppose government welfare payments to non-citizens just as we oppose welfare payments to all other persons.

    I suspect that we supported the right of humans to immigrate (and emigrate) long before that. I take issue with calling our current platform "Open Borders". Our current immigration plank clearly states in the Transition section that "We support limited control over the entry into our country of foreign nationals who pose a credible threat to security, health or property, however we assert that peaceful people should be allowed to cross borders peacefully." This is not an Open Borders position, rather one that recognizes that humans hold the right to travel.

    There are many in the Party who consider themselves an anarchist. I am not one, but I do find the philosophy interesting. There are a few good books on the subject. Two that I often recommend are:

    I have found that most people who object to anarchist ideas being presented by libertarians have never really read much on the subject of anarchy or libertarianism.

    People have a right to trade their labor like any other value, good, or service. To regulate such trade is therefore to regulate people’s freedom to associate and freedom to travel. Today’s fervent rhetoric against “illegal immigration” reflects the prevalent notion that law should be obeyed regardless of its infringement on individual rights and lack of logic. If anything, people’s anger ought to be directed at the welfare State and at the police State required to enforce “our borders,” both of which continue to expose the ills of Communist thinking.

    Property owners ought to be able to determine who can and cannot travel on their property. Fortunately, by definition, the market highly favors those who invite and promote commerce with fellow travelers and residents, and it tends to disfavor those who isolate themselves from such commerce. - The Market for Liberty